Top Cast
Tamara Lynn Chambers
Dolores
Doug Walker
Nostalgia Critic
Malcolm Ray
Contestant #1
B
Brett Bonynge
Contestant #2
R
Robbie Allen
Bob
A
Alyssa Jackson
Barbara
P
Paul Rohan
Ben
J
Jimmy Melf
Reilly
H
Harry Locke IV
Julio
J
Jim Jarosz
Rolly the Fox/Practitioner
H
Heather Reusz
Atlantis Somerset
N
Nick La Banca
Nautical Nineties Narrator
J
Justin Hoffman
"Spin My Helm" Singer
M
McKane Searle
"Spin My Helm" Bassist
J
James Banasiak
"Spin My Helm" Drummer